Susie McAllister and Gary Morton are connected in the public record by a 1996 marriage that joined a former LPGA Tour golfer with a comedian and producer best remembered as Lucille Ball’s second husband. Very little about their private life together has been made public, yet their names came back into the news in 2010, when a fight over Ball’s personal items reached a Los Angeles courtroom. This article explains who each of them was, what is confirmed about their marriage, how the auction dispute unfolded, and why many pages online about the couple should be treated with caution.
Quick Facts About Susie McAllister and Gary Morton
| Detail | Susie McAllister | Gary Morton |
|---|---|---|
| Full name | Mary H. “Susie” McAllister (later known publicly as Susie Morton) | Born Morton Goldaper |
| Born | August 27, 1947, Beaumont, Texas | December 19, 1924, New York City (some older listings give other years) |
| Known for | LPGA Tour golfer with one tour win in 1975 | Comedian, television and film producer, husband of Lucille Ball |
| Marriage | Married in 1996; the exact date and place are not publicly confirmed | Married in 1996; he was previously married to Ball from 1961 until her death in 1989 |
| Later public event | Consigned Ball-related items to Heritage Auction Galleries in 2010 | Died March 30, 1999, in Palm Springs, California, at age 74 |
Who Were Susie McAllister and Gary Morton?
Gary Morton was a stand-up comedian who worked the resort circuit before moving into production, and he became widely known after he married Lucille Ball in 1961. Public biographies describe him as a producer connected to Ball’s later television work, and a 1999 obituary also credited him as executive producer of the 1983 film All the Right Moves, which starred Tom Cruise. He and Ball stayed married until her death in 1989, and he died of lung cancer a decade later.
Susie McAllister built her public profile in a very different field. According to her official LPGA biography, she studied at Lamar University, where she was a strong tennis player, and her golf game developed after she met the respected California instructor Vernon Brown while working at the Houston Astrodome. She won the Beaumont city title as an amateur in 1968, later moved to California, and turned professional in 1971. Her profile on Wikipedia, which draws on LPGA records, lists a tour career from 1971 to 1992.
McAllister’s best-known result came on July 6, 1975, when she won the Wheeling Ladies Classic in West Virginia with a 54-hole total of 212, four under par, finishing one stroke ahead of Jan Ferraris. It was her only LPGA victory, and she was one of five first-time winners that season. She also placed fourth at the 1976 U.S. Women’s Open, which remains one of the strongest finishes of her career.
The 1996 Marriage and What Is Actually Known
The link between Susie McAllister and Gary Morton is confirmed by several mainstream sources, including his 1999 obituary coverage and reference biographies, which state that they married in 1996, seven years after Ball died. Morton was in his early seventies at the time, and the obituary described McAllister as his wife of three years. Beyond that, the public record is thin: no reliable source I found gives the wedding date, the location, or how the two first met.
That gap matters because some websites fill it with invented detail. At least one content-farm page describes an elaborate wedding with vows, a reception, and “memorable quotes,” and it lists the couple as a 30-year-old graphic designer and a 32-year-old software engineer from a town called Springfield. None of that matches the real people, whose ages and careers are documented elsewhere, so the page appears to be auto-generated filler written to catch searches for their names. Any article that offers a minute-by-minute wedding account should be treated as unreliable.
What Happened to Lucille Ball’s Belongings
After Morton died in 1999, news reports say he left the remaining personal belongings of Lucille Ball to McAllister. She kept them for more than ten years. According to Heritage Auction Galleries, the collection included love letters exchanged between Ball and Morton, photographs, a Rolls-Royce, and other keepsakes, and McAllister decided to sell it in 2010. A law-firm commentary on the case notes that Ball’s estate was reportedly worth about $40 million when she died and was shared by her two children, Lucie Arnaz and Desi Arnaz Jr., and Morton, although that dollar figure is an estimate rather than an official number.
The 2010 Auction and the Court Fight
The sale was scheduled for July 17, 2010, in Beverly Hills and online. Shortly before it, Lucie Arnaz Luckinbill, Ball’s daughter with Desi Arnaz, objected, saying some of the items belonged to her. According to the Associated Press, both sides agreed that Arnaz was entitled to her mother’s personal effects under Ball’s estate planning, but McAllister’s lawsuit argued that Arnaz had abandoned the items when they were distributed after Ball’s death. Reports at the time said Arnaz initially wanted 13 of the more than 150 items, including eight love letters and five lifetime achievement awards.
A Los Angeles judge sided with Arnaz at one stage but required her to post a $250,000 bond for a restraining order, according to reports citing the AP, and the bond became the obstacle she could not clear in time. The two women then reached a settlement. Heritage described the lawsuit as amicably resolved, withdrew five awards and a painting by Ratterman from the sale, and said it expected most or all of those pieces to go to a charitable institution, while Arnaz said the awards would be displayed in a museum honoring her mother. The love letters and the remaining lots went ahead at auction. Sale prices were not confirmed in the sources reviewed, so no figures are given here.
Common Confusion Around the Names
Several details are repeated incorrectly online. Some outlets spell her name as “McCallister,” some call her “Susie McAllister Morton,” and the 2010 coverage mostly referred to her as Susie Morton, which reflects her married name. A few blogs also misdescribe the letters as correspondence between Ball and Desi Arnaz, while the original auction and news reports say they were exchanged between Ball and Gary Morton. Another loose label is “stepmother,” which appears in some summaries even though McAllister married Ball’s widower long after Ball’s death and was not Lucie Arnaz’s stepparent in the usual sense.
Net worth claims are another weak spot. Low-quality sites list a figure of $950,000 for Morton, but they give no source, no method, and no date, so it should be regarded as unconfirmed.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long were Susie McAllister and Gary Morton married?
They were married for about three years, from 1996 until Morton’s death on March 30, 1999. The exact wedding date and venue have not been publicly confirmed by the sources reviewed.
Is Susie McAllister related to Lucille Ball?
No blood relation is reported. She became connected to Ball’s family only through her marriage to Ball’s former husband, years after Ball’s death in 1989.
What name does Susie McAllister use now?
News coverage in 2010 used Susie Morton, and some sources combine the names as Susie McAllister Morton. Golf records list her under McAllister, her name during her LPGA career.
Is Susie McAllister still alive?
Public profiles list her as living, and no credible report of her death turned up in the sources reviewed. Her listed birth date, August 27, 1947, would make her 79 in 2026, but no verified recent personal updates are available.
Did Lucie Arnaz get her mother’s awards back?
According to Heritage Auction Galleries and news reports, five lifetime achievement awards and a painting were pulled from the auction as part of the settlement. Arnaz said the awards would go on display in a museum honoring her mother.
Conclusion
The story of Susie McAllister and Gary Morton is a modest one in terms of verified facts: a golfer with one LPGA win, a veteran comedian and producer, a 1996 marriage, and a widow who later sold a famous collection of keepsakes. What gives it lasting interest is the 2010 dispute, which was settled without any finding of wrongdoing against either side, and the reminder that famous estates can raise questions long after the original owners are gone. When reading about the couple, rely on official golf records, mainstream news coverage, and statements from the auction house rather than pages that supply details no one has confirmed.
Disclaimer: This article is for general information only and is based on publicly available reporting at the time of writing. It is not legal, financial, or biographical advice, and some details about private individuals are not publicly confirmed. Readers should consult primary sources and qualified professionals for any legal or estate matters.
EXPLORE MORE: What Happened to Rita Cosby and Curtis Sliwa? The Real Story Behind Their WABC Radio Show
Written by Hassan, founder and editor of NTX Magazine — an independent news and biography publication. Every article is researched and cross-checked against multiple public sources before publishing; see our Sourcing Standards page for details.
1 comment